COIN VALUE GUIDES · NICKELS

1927 Buffalo Nickel Value:No Mint Mark, D, S and Difficult High Grades

Separate an inexpensive worn Philadelphia nickel from the much harder Denver and San Francisco examples in high numerical grades.

In this article

Quick answer

1927 Buffalo Nickel does not have one universal price. For the Philadelphia ordinary issue, NGC’s guide lists $5 in Fine and $280 in Mint State 65. That source row was updated 08/20/2021; the guide was accessed November 16, 2026. These are dated retail references, not a fresh dealer buying offer.

The San Francisco issue shows why surviving quality matters. Its guide values rise much more sharply than Philadelphia’s as the condition improves. That difference is evidence to identify the mint carefully, not permission to call a soft strike an exceptionally preserved coin. Prices for altered, corroded or cleaned coins should not be inferred from problem-free certified guide entries.

Coin photos

1927-P nickel obverse: read the full date; F beneath it is Fraser’s initial.
1927-P nickel obverse: read the full date; F beneath it is Fraser’s initial.
1927-P nickel reverse: D or S belongs below FIVE CENTS; Philadelphia is blank.
1927-P nickel reverse: D or S belongs below FIVE CENTS; Philadelphia is blank.
1927-D nickel reverse: D or S belongs below FIVE CENTS; Philadelphia is blank.
1927-D nickel reverse: D or S belongs below FIVE CENTS; Philadelphia is blank.
1927-S nickel reverse: D or S belongs below FIVE CENTS; Philadelphia is blank.
1927-S nickel reverse: D or S belongs below FIVE CENTS; Philadelphia is blank.

Basics & coin story

The year sits in the later part of Fraser’s Buffalo nickel series, which continued through 1938. Collectors can often afford a worn Philadelphia example while finding that equivalent-looking mintmarked coins require closer examination and a different budget.

The San Francisco issue shows why surviving quality matters. Its guide values rise much more sharply than Philadelphia’s as the condition improves. That difference is evidence to identify the mint carefully, not permission to call a soft strike an exceptionally preserved coin. Follow the design and related dates in the Buffalo nickel series guide.

Identification at a glance
FeatureWhat to check
Type / denomination1927 Buffalo nickel / five cents
DesignerJames Earle Fraser
Standard alloy75% copper; 25% nickel
Nominal weight / diameter5.00 g / 21.2 mm
EdgePlain
Mint-mark positionReverse below FIVE CENTS; Philadelphia blank

Identification

Date and mint identification

Read the raised date on the portrait side and look below FIVE CENTS on the reverse for D or S; Philadelphia is blank.

The date-specific trap

The small F beneath the date is Fraser’s initial, not a fourth mint mark. Both the D and S belong on the reverse below FIVE CENTS. A photograph of the portrait alone does not establish the mint.

Wear, strike and surface condition

Examine both sides under even light. High-point smoothing from circulation is different from incomplete detail left by the dies. Hairlines, pitting, unnatural color and an altered date can prevent a problem-free grade even if some details remain sharp.

1927-D reverse detail: look below FIVE CENTS for D; the obverse F is a designer initial.
1927-D reverse detail: look below FIVE CENTS for D; the obverse F is a designer initial.

Condition & value

Amounts are in U.S. dollars. The final column gives each source row’s update date (month/day/year), separate from the access date of November 16, 2026. Published guides are reference estimates, not guaranteed buying offers or seller net proceeds. Obtain recent like-for-like completed comparisons for an actual transaction.

MS means Mint State. Proofs and attributed varieties are excluded from the ordinary entries.

Ordinary-issue comparisons: match mint, condition and source date
IssueGrade / conditionUSD referenceBasisSource updated
1927 no markGood$2NGC retail guide08/20/2021
1927 no markFine$5NGC retail guide08/20/2021
1927 no markExtremely Fine 40$20NGC retail guide08/20/2021
1927 no markMS63$85NGC retail guide08/20/2021
1927 no markMS65$280NGC retail guide08/20/2021
1927-DGood$3.50NGC retail guide08/20/2021
1927-DFine$20NGC retail guide08/20/2021
1927-DExtremely Fine 40$100NGC retail guide08/20/2021
1927-DMS63$420NGC retail guide08/20/2021
1927-DMS65$4250NGC retail guide08/20/2021
1927-SGood$3NGC retail guide11/03/2025
1927-SFine$17.50NGC retail guide11/03/2025
1927-SExtremely Fine 40$135NGC retail guide11/03/2025
1927-SMS63$2400NGC retail guide11/03/2025
1927-SMS65$13000NGC retail guide11/03/2025

Match the comparison to the coin

The San Francisco issue shows why surviving quality matters. Its guide values rise much more sharply than Philadelphia’s as the condition improves. That difference is evidence to identify the mint carefully, not permission to call a soft strike an exceptionally preserved coin.

What the ordinary table excludes

The numerical grade and the quality of the strike must both be considered. A weak horn or shallow reverse details do not automatically establish heavy wear, but neither do they justify an exceptionally high grade.

No regular Proof comparison for this date

This ordinary 1927 issue should not be priced as a modern collector Proof. U.S. Proof coin production had not yet resumed for this year; a mirrorlike appearance requires examination for polishing or other surface changes.

Obtain an actual selling comparison

Use the same date, mint, manufacture and grade, then inspect photographs for comparable surfaces. A completed sale, a retail guide estimate and an unsold asking price are different evidence. Do not add an auction record premium to an ordinary worn coin simply because the year matches.

Photograph both faces under even light and record the visible date and mint mark. HeriBase can help organize an initial photo-based identification; verify important mint, finish and variety details against the references before using a price. An app result is not a certified grade, authentication or purchase offer.

Summary

Identify the complete 1927 issue first, then compare the appropriate ordinary or collector category. The San Francisco issue shows why surviving quality matters. Its guide values rise much more sharply than Philadelphia’s as the condition improves. That difference is evidence to identify the mint carefully, not permission to call a soft strike an exceptionally preserved coin.

FAQ

How much is a 1927 nickel worth?

For the Philadelphia ordinary issue, NGC lists Fine at $5 and MS65 at $280, using its 08/20/2021 row. Mint, grade, surface problems and special manufacture must be matched; these are not guaranteed cash offers.

Where should I look for the mint mark?

Read the raised date on the portrait side and look below FIVE CENTS on the reverse for D or S; Philadelphia is blank.

What is often misidentified on the 1927 issue?

The small F beneath the date is Fraser’s initial, not a fourth mint mark. Both the D and S belong on the reverse below FIVE CENTS. A photograph of the portrait alone does not establish the mint.

Should I clean the coin before checking its value?

No. Cleaning can leave hairlines or altered surfaces and can change the market comparison. Photograph the coin as found, inspect it without rubbing, and obtain appropriate authentication for an unusual or potentially valuable piece.

Are Proofs included in the ordinary 1927 value table?

No. There is no regular Proof issue for this date to substitute for an ordinary circulation coin. Reflectivity alone does not create one.

Can HeriBase determine the final selling price?

HeriBase can assist an initial photo-based identification and help organize a collection. It is not a certified grade, an authentication guarantee or a binding purchase offer. Confirm important details before using a price reference.

References

References and further reading

References accessed November 16, 2026. Guide update dates, source publication dates and sale dates are distinct. No independent examination or current buying offer for a reader’s coin is implied.